Online Project Proposal Grading

Project proposals (click to see the proposals in the class Wiki place)

Grading form

INSTRUCTIONS: Read the proposal carefully, and try to understand as much as possible what the project is about. Refer to the project web page for what questions a good proposal should address, and check how well the proposal addresses each question, and assign grades accordingly. Please write down at least one sentence to justify the grade you give for each question. After you are finished, click on the "submit" button. If you have questions or are not sure about how to grade, contact the instructor before proceeding to grade.

Grader ID: Project ID (See the Wiki place):
1. Problem definition (20 points): Grade points:
Justification:
2. Problem significance (15 points) Grade points:
Justification:
3. Literature connection (10 points) Grade points:
Justification:
4. Method description (40 points) Grade points:
Justification:
5. Evaluation (if applicable) (10 points) Grade points:
Note: When this criterion is not applicable (e.g., for an evaluation research itself), full points should be granted.
Justification:
6. Plan/Timeline (5 points) Grade points:
Justification: